Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Tongues, Prophecy, and Worship

Psalm 117                             Isaiah 28:9-13                        1 Corinthians 14       
(and 1 Peter 1:18–19 to be read during the sermon by me)
Tongues, Prophecy, and Worship

Think of a physical gift that you would consider priceless…something essential to your happiness and wellbeing as a believer. I know you’re thinking of Jesus and salvation, but for now, think of a physical gift other than Jesus.
Thought of that gift? Do you have it in mind? Good.
Now I want you to read the following two verses with me.
"For you know that it was not with perishable things such as silver or gold that you were redeemed from the empty way of life handed down to you from your ancestors, but with the precious blood of Christ, a lamb without blemish or spot." (1 Peter 1:18–19)
Let’s read that again, shall we? Did you see that?
That priceless gift is…your fellow believer. Each of us has been redeemed with the precious and priceless blood of Jesus, so you cannot put a price on your life or mine. And here comes the best part: God has gifted us to each other. You are God’s priceless gift to me, and I am God’s priceless gift to you. 
So, now I’m going to do something totally not me and ask you to stand up, and to turn to the people around you, and to look them in the eye and say, “You are God’s gift to me”. 
Just as the eye is a gift to the foot and the hand is a gift to the ear, so we are God’s gifts to each other to make us function together as his Body…his hands and his feet here on earth.

Now, let’s turn to 1 Corinthians 14. Tongues, prophecy, other supernatural gifts, and the puzzling command for women to be silent can so capture our attention that we miss Paul’s point which is the purpose of the Church. And Paul has already told us what that purpose is.
At the end of chapter 12, he says, “…I am showing you the most excellent way.” And then, in Chapter 13, he spells out biblical love. Now, in chapter 14, he goes on to show how the gifts that have divided them can instead unify and edify the whole body.
In Paul’s mind, the question has never been, “Which gift do I have?” It is not even, “Which gift is the most impressive?” The question is and always will be: “How do I use what God has given me to exhibit biblical love to the priceless gifts God has given to me?” That is the governing principle of this entire chapter.
Paul begins: “(So,) pursue love and (or you could say, but also) eagerly desire gifts of the Spirit, especially prophecy.”
I want you to notice the balance here: pursue love AND desire spiritual gifts. Paul will not let us choose one instead of the other. The gifts of the Spirit are instruments through which God’s love is expressed within the body of Christ.
Now, of course, as we’ve said before, the gifts are not the goal. Love is the goal because of all the gifts love alone is eternal. Nevertheless, in the present, the gifts are the means by which the Spirit enables us to love and serve one another. And this brings us back to something we have already spoken about before.
God is love. So, if we belong to him, his character ought to be visible in our words, our actions, and the way we use our gifts.
But love does not simply happen to us. We must practise it and grow in it. That is why Paul says, “Pursue love.” 
But as we’ve already seen, he also says, “eagerly desire spiritual gifts.”
So the question we should be asking as believers is: “How can I express biblical love by using the gifts God has given me?”
That is what Paul means by spiritual maturity. Gifts must build the body.
In this chapter, Paul begins by comparing tongues with prophecy. He says that the person speaking in a tongue speaks to God, because nobody understands what is being said. In other words, whatever these “tongues” are, they are not intelligible languages, but spiritual languages. But on the other hand, the person who prophesies speaks to people “for their strengthening, encouraging and comfort.”
Now, perhaps we need to more closely define what is meant by the word “prophecy”. Prophecy can involve foretelling…predicting the future. But in Scripture it is more frequently forthtelling: proclaiming God’s truth into a particular situation.
The Old Testament prophets chiefly applied God’s truth, revealed primarily in the Torah, to his people. They challenged, encouraged, warned, convicted, and called them back to faithfulness. 
And this is what I think Paul has in mind here.
In the gathered church, prophecy is the Spirit-enabled proclamation and application of God's truth so that God's people are strengthened, encouraged and comforted. However, because it is being spoken publicly, it is also subject to evaluation.
And that is important. Nobody in the Church ever gets to say, “God told me this, therefore you must accept it.” No, Paul later says that the other church members must carefully evaluate what was said. In other words, all prophetic speech, including my sermons, is subject to, and accountable to, biblical truth. 
That should make us humble whenever we stand up to teach or speak. The words of anyone claiming to speak for God must always be tested against Scripture.
However, Paul goes on to say that “The one who prophesies is greater than the one who speaks in tongues, unless that person interprets, so that the church may be edified.”
And the key word here is the last word: edified. The way we know whether or not the use of a spiritual gift is loving is simply whether it builds up the body or breaks down the body.
In this light, let’s quickly look at the difficult subject of tongues. I think Paul is remarkably clear about something that we sometimes miss. He does not deny that the gift of tongues is genuine. In fact, he says explicitly: “I thank God that I speak in tongues more than all of you.”
So Paul is not attacking the gift. As always, his concern is how the gift is used when the church gathers.
So, I think it would be good for us to figure out what this gift of tongues is because the same word seems to be used in Scripture to refer to known languages as well as unknown (or unintelligible) languages. 
And I think a good place for us to start is Acts 2. At Pentecost, people gathered in Jerusalem from many nations heard the disciples declaring God’s mighty works in their own languages. So, the miracle was understandable (or known) speech. And the same pattern seems to appear when the Spirit comes upon new groups of believers elsewhere in Acts, such as in Acts 10 and Acts 19. 
“Although scholars debate whether the ‘tongues’ in Acts (19:6) were ecstatic speech or recognizable languages, the safest narrative reading within Luke’s literary framework is to understand them as known human languages in continuity with Acts 2. Luke consistently presents tongues as public, verifiable signs accompanying key redemptive-historical expansions of the church (Acts 2; 10; 19), and he gives no indication that the phenomenon in (Caesarea and in) Ephesus differs in kind from Pentecost.” 
However, Corinth appears different in one crucial respect: those present could not understand the languages being spoken. So, Paul’s practical question is: What good does that do the church?
Imagine me speaking for ten minutes (you wish) in a language none of you understands. However genuine and spiritually inspired I may be, what have I given you? Nothing you can understand or respond to.
And that is precisely Paul's point. Paul is not asking whether the gift is authentic. He is asking whether its public use is loving. You see, something can be genuinely spiritual and still be used unlovingly. That was Paul’s concern in Corinth: real gifts were being used for self-elevation rather than service.
Their desire for attention, status, and spiritual prestige contradicted chapter 13. And that is why Paul says he would rather speak five intelligible words to instruct others than ten thousand words in a tongue.
As Douglas Moo puts it, Paul does not disparage the gift of tongues; rather, he is saying that “using intelligible words to instruct others” is the much better option. 
You see, the gift is not the problem. It is the self-centred use of the gift that is the problem.
At this point, Paul gives us several illustrations of instruments that must make distinguishable sounds…a flute, a harp, and a trumpet that must give a clear call. Imagine being on a battlefield and hearing a trumpet. But you can’t tell whether the call means “advance,” “retreat,” “assemble,” or “attack.”
The sound may be beautiful, but if nobody understands it, it has failed in its purpose. And Paul says: “So it is with you.” The church must speak in a way that people can understand. Why? Because intelligibility is an act of love.
If I communicate helpful truth in language you cannot understand, I have not served you. Complicated teaching that leaves you knowing less, or theological language used to display my knowledge, spirituality, or education, misses the point entirely.
Love compels me to ask: Can the other person understand me? And that is why Paul says: “Since you are eager for the gifts of the Spirit, try to excel in those that build up the church.” That is Christian maturity.
So, Paul encourages those speaking in unintelligible tongues to pray for the gift of interpretation. Now, if I understand verse 13 correctly, the speaker should pray for that gift for themselves, rather than necessarily relying on a second person to interpret. Either way, Paul’s concern is not to prohibit the gift, but to ensure that its public use is understood by all.
Paul then says something particularly interesting in verse 14: “I will pray with my spirit, but I will also pray with my understanding; I will sing with my spirit, but I will also sing with my understanding.”
For Paul, the spiritual and the intellectual belong together. Christian worship engages the whole person: we love God with our heart and our mind.
This, of course, raises the question of how can the person beside us say “Amen” if they do not understand? You see, worship is not just about me and God; it is about us collectively and God. We gather as the body and therefore, what I do affects you, and what you do affects me.
So private and public use of gifts must be distinguished. Paul says he speaks in tongues himself, but among believers he prefers five understandable words to ten thousand that nobody can comprehend.
Please note that he is not denying the private use of the gift. Rather, he is insisting that public worship must be ordered around the edification of the whole body.
And this is where Paul's quotation from Isaiah becomes so powerful. He quotes Isaiah 28: “With other tongues and through the lips of foreigners I will speak to this people, but even then, they will not listen to me.” The background to this quotation is illuminating because Isaiah was speaking to people who had already rejected God's clear and understandable word.
God had spoken plainly to them, but they refused to listen and so eventually God's judgment came through the lips of foreign conquerors. They heard languages they could not understand and that was the judgement.
So Paul applies that warning to Corinth with devastating irony: speech they treated as proof of spiritual superiority could instead signal spiritual alienation, making people who belong feel like outsiders. That is the opposite of what the church should be.
The church should welcome outsiders into God’s presence. Consequently, if an unbeliever hears only unintelligible spiritual language, they may conclude, “These people are out of their minds.” But clearly proclaimed truth, on the other hand, may expose the secrets of their heart, convict them of their meaningless ways, and lead them to recognise that God is really among us.
So, Paul’s emphasis is on our encounter with the living God, not an impressive spiritual performance. The church is not a spiritual theatre; we are here to help one another encounter God and so, everything we do must be done in love.
And now Paul brings the whole discussion together.
He says: “When you come together, each of you has a hymn, or a word of instruction, a revelation, a tongue or an interpretation. (But) everything must be done so that the church may be built up.”
Notice that Paul does not picture a congregation where only one person contributes. These church services were obviously very different in form to ours…and, dare I say, much, much longer. 
Be that as it may, Paul says that the Spirit has distributed these gifts throughout the body, not merely to a select few. But Paul also does not imagine everybody exercising those gifts simultaneously, because love requires restraint. Perhaps this is one of the most important lessons in this chapter. While everyone is encouraged to use their gifts for the benefit of everyone else, each one of us is being checked in some way.
The tongue-speaker, the prophet, the person wishing to speak or evaluate…all are checked. So too, in the difficult final section, are those interrupting or publicly challenging or evaluating others.
Not because sharing the gifts is bad, but because the body matters more than the individual expression of the gift.
So, Paul tells us that only two or three may speak in tongues…and only one at a time…and only if there is an interpretation. If there is no interpretation, the person should remain silent in the assembly.
Two or three prophets may speak. The others should evaluate. And if another revelation comes to someone sitting down, the first speaker should give them a chance to speak as well.
As Paul says: “For you can all prophesy in turn so that everyone may be instructed and encouraged.” “In turn” means that no gift entitles anyone to dominate. His point is that in the use of the gifts, the Holy Spirit does not remove self-control: having something to say does not compel us to say it immediately. We can wait and listen. Sometimes the most spiritual thing we can do is remain silent.
And speaking about being silent, we now come to the passage that has caused enormous difficulty in the church: “Women should remain silent in the churches.”
Now, we must read this statement carefully alongside chapter 11, where Paul already describes women praying and prophesying in the gathered church. So, whatever he means here, it cannot be an absolute prohibition on speaking in the assembly without contradicting what he has already written.
It is important to note that the immediate context in which this statement is found, concerns evaluating prophecy. So, it is possible that some women were publicly questioning their husbands (or worse, other women’s husbands) during the assembly. In a Roman colony such as Corinth, this could be perceived as a serious breach of social and marital propriety, especially when one married woman questioned another woman’s husband.
There is an illuminating speech of Cato the Elder recorded in the Roman historian Livy’s “History of Rome”. In the speech Cato rebukes Roman women who were publicly approaching magistrates and other men. He says, “For my part, I blushed when, a short while ago, I walked through the midst of a band of women. Had I not been restrained by modesty and respect for the dignity of some of them rather than by fear, lest I should be mobbed by them, I should have said: ‘What sort of practice is this, running out into the streets and blocking the roads and (here comes the important bit) speaking to other women’s husbands? Could you not have asked your own husbands the same thing at home?’”  
So Paul’s concern appears to be public interrogation of male prophets by women in a cultural setting where that could be considered socially improper. In other words, this is not a total ban on women speaking in the church service as that would contradict 1 Corinthians 11:5. In this case, as with all the others, the principle remains the same: love restrains itself for the sake of the body.
So, what Paul is saying here is that there are circumstances in which even a legitimate question must wait. Sometimes the question can be asked later. Sometimes it can be discussed at home. Sometimes we must simply listen. And again, the principle is not “Who has the right to speak?” The principle is: What will build up the body? That is Paul's concern from beginning to end. Order is not the enemy of the Spirit.
Consequently, Paul says: “For God is not a God of disorder but of peace.” That does not mean that a Spirit-filled church is lifeless or that worship must be cold and mechanical or that spontaneity is wrong. It means that the freedom of the Spirit is never freedom from love and love exercises restraint when restraint is the loving thing to do.
And so Paul finishes: “Therefore, my brothers and sisters, be eager to prophesy, and do not forbid speaking in tongues. But everything should be done in a fitting and orderly way.”
Notice how balanced Paul is. He does not forbid the use of spiritual gifts. He just tells us to use them properly to build up or edify the whole body.
And that brings us back to where we began. “Pursue love.”
Of course, the gifts matter. Prophecy matters. Teaching matters. Encouragement, prayer, and singing all matter. Every gift that God gives matters.
But none of these gifts are given so that we can draw attention to ourselves. They are given so that Christ may be seen in all of us as we are God’s most precious gifts to each other and to the world.
Perhaps the simplest way to summarise 1 Corinthians 14 is this: The God of love gives us gifts, and the God of love teaches us how to use them. And when the church exercises restraint and does all things in an orderly fashion for the sake of the edification of all, Paul says something extraordinary can happen.
The outsider can experience the divine when they walk through our doors. The broken can find healing. The confused can find truth. The unbeliever can encounter God.
And that is exactly what we want. Not that people should see how gifted we are, but that, through the way we love one another, they should see Jesus.

Shall we pray?
© Johannes W H van der Bijl 2026

van der Bijl, Johannes W H, 1 Corinthians: A Life in Letters. Carlisle: Langham Publishing, 2026, 277.
Moo, Douglas, A Theology of Paul. Biblical Theology of the New Testament. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2021, 150.
See van der Bijl, 279.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Are We Better Than Jesus?

Luke 19:1-10

Are We Better Than Jesus?

I want to start this talk by asking you to think of someone you would rather not be friends with. 

Perhaps it is someone at your school. Perhaps there is a boy or girl whom nobody wants to play with. Perhaps there is someone who always causes trouble. 

Or maybe it is someone in your neighbourhood or even in your family. Someone you avoid. Someone who has hurt you. 

Now, keep that person in mind as we meet a man named Zacchaeus.

Zacchaeus was a chief tax collector. He worked for the Romans who ruled Israel, and he had become rich at other people’s expense. To his neighbours, he was not simply unpopular: he was a traitor and a thief. They saw a sinner, not someone to befriend.

Then Jesus came to Jericho. Zacchaeus wanted to see him, but he was too short to see over the crowd. So he ran ahead and climbed a sycamore tree. Here was a man with money and power, yet he could not even get a glimpse of Jesus.

Now, there is something very interesting about a Sycamore tree. A Sycamore tree was normally planted outside the city or village because its roots were so large that they would damage foundations and buildings. So, in one sense, this tree serves as an image of rejection, of being excluded or pushed outside.

Jesus knew his whole story: the money he had taken, the people he had hurt, the things nobody else knew. Yet Jesus stopped beneath the tree, looked up and said, “Zacchaeus, hurry and come down, for I must stay at your house today.”

Notice that he did not say: “Zacchaeus, come down. I need to have a serious conversation with you about your life.” Nor did he say, “Zacchaeus, change your life, and perhaps then I will welcome you.” No, Jesus said, “I must stay at your house today.” He did not wait for Zacchaeus to become respectable. He invited himself into Zacchaeus’ life.

Now, in the First Century, eating together meant more than just sharing a meal. When you had a meal with someone you were saying, “I am willing to share my life with you.” And so the crowd complained, “He has gone in to be the guest of a man who is a sinner.” 

And the contrast is startling: While they saw someone to keep out, Jesus saw someone to seek and save.

Was Jesus approving of his sin? No. But a doctor does not help the sick by keeping away from them. Jesus came close to the person who needed saving. His welcome did not make wrongdoing harmless; it opened the way to change.

And Zacchaeus did change. He promised half his possessions to the poor and fourfold repayment to anyone he had cheated. This was more than saying “Sorry.” He was making things right. His response was practical and costly: grace was changing how he lived.

And so Jesus said, “Today salvation has come to this house.” 

Now return to the person you thought of at the beginning. Imagine Jesus stopping for them. He knows their whole story, including the wrong they have done to you and to others. Yet he is willing to draw near. Would we welcome them or would we join the grumbling crowd?

Are we better than Jesus? More holy than Jesus? If he is willing to welcome someone, who are we to declare them beyond his reach? Afterall, don’t we also need his forgiveness? We must not turn the grace we have received into a privilege we deny to others.

That does not mean pretending the hurt never happened or that repentance does not matter. Zacchaeus sinned…just like all of us…but he also confessed his sin and made restitution…because Jesus befriended him first. Jesus’ welcome came before his response. The Gospel is not “become good enough, then I will welcome you.” Jesus comes looking for us, and his grace changes us.

But perhaps you hear this story differently. Perhaps you do not identify with the crowd at all. Perhaps you see yourself as Zacchaeus. You want to see Jesus, but you think people don’t think you’re good enough. Their words or attitudes tell you that you are too sinful, that someone with your past does not belong.

Luke tells us that the crowd prevented Zacchaeus from seeing Jesus although he does not say they deliberately blocked him. But perhaps that is how the judgement of others feels to you: like a crowd you cannot see past. Hear this: their verdict is not Jesus’ verdict. He stopped for Zacchaeus. He knew his name. His past did not put him beyond Jesus’ reach.

You do not have to hide your need or make yourself worthy before seeking him. The same Jesus who called Zacchaeus down from the tree came to seek and save the lost. There is room in this story for you, too.

So there are two questions for us today. 

a) If we are among the crowd: will we make room for the person Jesus wants to welcome, or do we think that we are better than Jesus? 

b) If we feel more like Zacchaeus: will we trust in the welcome of Jesus more than the crowd’s judgement?


Shall we pray?

© Johannes W H van der Bijl 2026


Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Autumn Newsletter

Johann and Louise: Training Disciples to Make Disciples in the Netherlands

Despite the annual reoccurrence of Remembrance Day/Armistice Day/Veteran’s Day, we are prone to forget that fallen humanity is inherently destructive. We tend to be breakers, not builders.

But, if Genesis 3 teaches us anything, it is that God never gives up on us.

Adam and Eve had broken their perfect world through disobedience, and yet God came looking for them. 
And Deuteronomy 7 reminds us that God loves us not because we are impressive, but simply because he chooses to love us. Indeed, that is one of the main fundamental principles of the Gospel…that while we still sinners, Jesus died for us. 

And the thief on the cross reminds us that, even at the very last moment, it is never too late to turn to Jesus.
We are also taught in Scripture that God doesn’t give up on us when we are sincerely wrong. Job's friends had confidently proclaimed some very bad theology, yet God gave them the opportunity to repent. And Paul’s letters reveal a heart that was not prone to disown even the deluded.

This gives us tremendous encouragement as we look at the state of the Church in Europe today.
There is certainly plenty to worry about. Christians are in the decided minority in most European countries. Governments are telling us to prepare for possible power cuts, food shortages, cyber-attacks and even the likelihood of yet another Great War. But while we should be sensible and prepared, we don't want fear to become the lens through which we see the future.

So, Louise and I have chosen to focus on Jesus as our King…the universal Monarch who is still seated on the throne, ever reigning until all his enemies are placed firmly under his feet. We pray that we, like Paul, might be content in all circumstances. Indeed, my prayer is for God’s presence to be so pervasive that the darkness will not be able to penetrate. 

We truly believe that God has not abandoned his Church. His plans have not been derailed. He has promised never to leave us or forsake us, and we know that he works all things together for the good of those who love him. The battle ultimately belongs to the Lord.

And this is why we remain deeply hopeful about the Church in Europe. In fact, we don't believe God has given up on the Church of England, the denomination we serve in as missionaries through it as well as to it. The newly elected General Synod is undoubtedly one of the most polarised Synods we have seen, and there are significant theological battles ahead, but our response must not be despair or defeat or desertion. It must be prayer, truth, courage, and grace. 

We have seen some very promising signs recently. Numerous biblically orthodox believers have taken up the cause…some, like Nicky Gumbel, have been elected to Synod…many are praying earnestly for biblical truth to prevail. 24/7 prayer groups are popping up everywhere. 

So, may we please ask that you will join us in praying for every member of the Synod…the bishops, clergy, and the lay representatives. Pray that those who love Jesus and his Word will have wisdom and strength and courage and that truth will triumph, not through hostility, but through faithful Christian witness. May we win our challengers, not lose them. Pray for those who have their own personal agendas, that they might be enlightened by the Holy Spirit himself.

But there is still yet another reason for hope. We are seeing signs of a spiritual awakening among the younger generation, particularly the Gen Z. Across Europe and beyond, young people who have grown up in a profoundly secular culture are beginning to ask questions about God…about meaning, truth, and the reality of eternity. Many are discovering Jesus for the first time, and they are hungry for something authentic and something deeper than the empty promises of this culture.

So we are praying for a flood of new believers, particularly among this emerging generation: young men and women who love Jesus, hunger for Scripture, cherish truth, and are unafraid to ask difficult questions. 

Indeed, we might do well to ask what might happen if an entire generation discovered the transforming power of the Gospel? What might happen if an entire body of the very immigrants everyone fears so much were ushered into the Kingdom of God through dreams and visions? Perhaps some of the very people who will shape the future of the Church have not yet walked through its doors.

That is why we are here. Europe may be a dark and difficult spiritual battleground…indeed, one of the most difficult we have ever encountered…but it is also a mission field filled with people for whom God demonstrated his love by dying for them while they were still his enemies. After all, Scripture teaches us that where sin abounds, grace abounds all the more. 

So we choose not spend our days looking anxiously at the darkness. We choose to look to Jesus. We choose to pray and to pray fervently and ceaselessly. We choose to boldly proclaim the Gospel. We choose to stand for truth. And we choose to trust our universal King, because Jesus is still reigning and the story is not over yet.

Please pray with us for an outpouring of God’s Holy Spirit upon us all…pray that God might purge the Church of all that does not honour or glorify him. Pray that the Holy Spirit would convict us all of sin, of righteousness, and of judgement. In short, pray for revival.

As Pete Grieg says, “The cross proves once and for all that Satan’s worst atrocities can now, in Christ, become God’s best opportunities.” (Dirty Glory, 265) 

Pray for us as we endeavour to disciple the new believers and the many new attendees who are coming to Christ Church.

God willing, we will be in the US next year. After spending some time with our children and grandchildren in Boston, we hope to head out West to visit our faithful supporters there. We plan to be in the Carolinas from Tuesday April 6 to Wednesday April 28. Part of that time we will be at Ridgecrest for the SAMS-USA reunion, but other than that we are open to visiting churches, Bible studies, book clubs, small groups, etc. Please let us know if you would like for us to come to see you and when. 

Please pray for our planning as right now, we are struggling to secure a vehicle as our usual missionary rental companies now require a valid US license. We only have Dutch licenses.

Please pray also for our fur baby, Mr Pips, that we will find the best place for him to stay for the six weeks.
We simply cannot express how grateful we are for every one of you who are part of our ministry…you are all members of a team that, by God’s grace, will push the very portals of hell and will rob it of many precious blood-bought souls.

May the Light always shine brighter in our lives than all the darkness in the world.
Love, hugs, and blessings
Johann and Louise

Facebook
Website
Email
Twitter
Support Us
Johann and Louise spent two years helping to develop the St. Frumentius Seminary in Gambella, Ethiopia. They then worked in Southern Africa, serving in seven southern African countries, while continuing to work with the Diocese of Egypt, North Africa through engaging in a disciple making movement in order to grow the body of Christ. They are now serving in Heiloo, the Netherlands.
Copyright © 2016 Society of Anglican Missionaries and Senders, All rights reserved.
www.sams-usa.org
    

Our mailing address is:
PO Box 399 Ambridge PA 15003
Attention to: Johann and Louise van der Bijl

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

A More Excellent Way

Psalm 103:8-14    1 Corinthians 12:1–11    1 Corinthians 12:12-31     1 Corinthians 13:1-13

A More Excellent Way

There is a question that runs beneath much of Paul's correspondence with the Corinthians and that is: What does it actually mean to be a spiritually mature believer?

It is an important question because the Corinthians seemed to have developed a rather distorted understanding of spirituality. Some appeared to have measured their spiritual standing by the gifts they possessed, the knowledge they had acquired, the eloquence with which they spoke, and the recognition they received from others. Certain gifts had become markers of status, and those who possessed them had begun to regard themselves as more important than those who did not.

But this was not simply a disagreement about spiritual gifts. It was symptomatic of something much deeper…it was symptomatic of a failure to understand the very nature of the Church and what it means to belong to Jesus Christ.

We have already encountered this problem in Paul's discussion of the Lord's Supper. Those who had more were behaving as though they were more important, while those who had little were being humiliated and neglected. The very meal intended to proclaim the self-giving love of Jesus had become an occasion for division and selfishness.

Now Paul turns his attention to spiritual gifts, but his concern remains essentially the same. The question is not how impressive our gifts are, but how we use them. The question is not who is the most spiritual, but whether our lives demonstrate the character of the Spirit who dwells within us…of the Saviour who humbly gave up everything in his bid to save us…of the God who reveals himself as the God of love and mercy and grace.

But as Paul develops his argument, he leads us towards one of the most profound passages in the New Testament. He is going to show the Corinthians, and us, that there is something infinitely more important than any spiritual gift, however remarkable it might be. There is, as he puts it, a more excellent way.

Paul begins by addressing those who consider themselves spiritual. The Greek word pneumatikos can refer either to spiritual people or spiritual things, but in the context of this letter, Paul seems particularly concerned with those who regard themselves as spiritually superior.

He reminds them of their former lives as pagans, when they were led astray by mute idols…lifeless objects, incapable of revealing anything to those who worshipped them. But then he contrasts the lifeless idols of their previous religious lives with the Holy Spirit who animates the Church as a living community. "No one speaking in the Spirit of God ever says, 'Jesus is accursed!' and no one can say, 'Jesus is Lord' except in the Holy Spirit." (12:3, ESV) 

In other words, if true spirituality begins with an honest and true confession that Jesus is Lord, then whoever makes such a confession should be regarded as a spiritual person. That levels the playing field, so to speak. Everyone who truly confesses Jesus as Lord is spiritual…so no one can claim to be more (or less) spiritual than the other. It is the Holy Spirit who enables us to recognise, acknowledge, and submit to the lordship of Jesus. And so true spirituality is not determined by the possession of extraordinary abilities, but by our relationship with Jesus.

Paul then develops this thought by explaining that although there are different gifts, different forms of service, and different kinds of activity, they all originate in the same God. And I want you to notice the repetition: Different gifts, but the same Spirit. Different forms of service, but the same Lord. Different activities, but the same God.

Paul is deliberately removing any grounds for spiritual boasting. The Greek word diaireseis, which is sometimes translated as varieties or diversities, carries the sense of different allocations. God distributes different gifts to different people. They are not achievements to be accumulated, nor rewards for those who have attained some higher spiritual standing. They are gracious provisions of God for the interdependent building up of the whole church body.

Paul makes their purpose unmistakably clear: "To each is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good." (12:7) And this purpose is crucial. The gifts are not given for personal fulfilment, individual recognition, or spiritual advancement. They are given for the benefit of the whole community.

At this point, Paul offers several examples: words of wisdom and knowledge, faith, gifts of healing, works of power, prophecy, discernment of spirits, different kinds of tongues and the interpretation of tongues. 

Now, I think Paul is just giving us a few examples here rather than an exhaustive list of spiritual gifts, because the thrust of his argument is not the gifts themselves but the fact that each one is given by the same Spirit and therefore one gift is not more important than the other. All are necessary as each one contributes to the building up of the whole body. 

And so we need not settle every question concerning the precise nature of each gift to understand Paul's central argument. "All these are empowered by one and the same Spirit, who apportions to each one individually as he wills." (12:11)

In other words, the Spirit determines what is given and to whom it is given. Consequently, there is no room for pride, competition or boasting. No one can claim superiority because of a gift, because no one has given that gift to themselves. And equally, no one should feel inferior because they have not received a particular gift that someone else might have been given. God has not overlooked them but is wisely creating an interdependent community in which every member has a contribution to make.

The principle is wonderfully simple: The gifts are different, the recipients are different, but the Giver is the same. And the purpose of every gift is the same: the building up of the whole Church.

Paul now moves from the gifts themselves to the relationship between those who receive them. He introduces one of the most familiar illustrations in Scripture: the human body. "Just as the body is one and has many members, and all the members of the body, though many, are one body, so it is with Christ. For in one Spirit we were all baptised into one body – Jews or Greeks, slaves or free – and all were made to drink of one Spirit." (12:12-13)

I think that here, Paul is deliberately taking us back to the Exodus imagery he has already introduced in chapter 10. Just as the Israelites were baptised into Moses in the cloud and in the sea, and all drank from the spiritual Rock, so believers have been incorporated into a new covenant community through the work of the Holy Spirit. Our backgrounds may be different. Our social standing, ethnicity, education, abilities, and experiences may be different. But the same Spirit has brought us into one body.

There is no privileged entrance into the Church. No one belongs more fully than another. We are all equally dependent upon the grace of God.

And at this point, Paul begins to dismantle the assumptions that were creating division in Corinth. In the body, the foot cannot say that because it is not a hand it does not belong to the body. The ear cannot say that because it is not an eye it has no place. Nor can the eye dismiss the hand, or the head declare that it has no need of the feet. The absurdity of such thinking is obvious. If the entire body were an eye, there would be no hearing. If the whole body were an ear, there would be no sense of smell.

In other words, the body requires diversity to function properly. And so, “as it is, God arranged the members in the body, each one of them, as he chose." (12:18)

This is not accidental diversity. It is purposeful diversity. The God who formed our individual bodies in our mothers' wombs (Psalm 139:13–14) has also arranged the members of Christ's body according to his wisdom and purpose. We are not all meant to be the same. We are not all meant to possess the same gifts, perform the same tasks or exercise the same ministries. God has deliberately made us different because we need one another.

And this leads Paul to address two opposing problems. First, there are those who feel inferior because they do not possess the gifts or abilities that others seem to value. Second, there are those who consider themselves superior because they possess gifts that others do not.

Both attitudes are wrong. The first is wrong because no member should consider themselves unnecessary. The second is wrong because no member should consider themselves indispensable. Indeed, Paul turns the argument upside down: "On the contrary, the parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable." (12:22) And those parts we regard as less honourable we treat with greater honour. Those parts that are less presentable receive special modesty and attention.

Paul is making a profound point. The apparent importance of one part of the body is not necessarily an indication of its actual importance. Some of the most essential functions of the human body are performed by members that remain (thankfully) hidden from view.

The same is true of the Church. Not everyone stands at the front. Not everyone preaches, teaches, leads worship, or exercises a publicly recognised ministry. Some pray quietly, encourage the discouraged, visit the lonely, care for the sick, give generously, welcome strangers, and serve faithfully without ever receiving recognition. But these members are no less important. Indeed, without them the Church would be impoverished.

And here Paul returns to the problem that has been troubling him throughout this letter and that is “that there may be no division in the body, but that the members may have the same care for one another." (12:25) 

This is what unity actually looks like. It is not simply agreeing with one another, attending the same meetings, or belonging to the same congregation. It is having such a profound sense of belonging to one another that the suffering of another becomes our suffering, and the joy of another becomes our joy. "If one member suffers,” Paul says, “all suffer together; if one member is honoured, all rejoice together." (12:26) 

Remember the poorer members of the Corinthian congregation whom we encountered in chapter 11? Some were going hungry while others ate and drank to excess. Some were being humiliated and neglected while others enjoyed their privileged position. How could they possibly claim to be one body while behaving in this way? The Jerusalem church had demonstrated a very different understanding of Christian community. They shared what they possessed so that no one was left in need (Acts 2:44–47; 4:34–35).

So, Paul is reminding the Corinthians that the Church cannot be healthy when some members are flourishing at the expense of others. We cannot claim to love Christ while neglecting those who belong to him. We cannot claim to be spiritual while remaining indifferent to the suffering of our brothers and sisters. We cannot claim to be one body while behaving as though the needs of others have nothing to do with us.

Paul concludes this section by reminding them that God has appointed different ministries within the Church: apostles, prophets, teachers, those who perform works of power, those who exercise gifts of healing, helping and guidance, and those who speak in tongues. But his questions are deliberately rhetorical. Are all apostles? Are all prophets? Are all teachers? Do all perform miracles? Do all speak in tongues? Of course not! The Church is not meant to be a collection of identical people competing for the same positions. It is a community of different people, with different gifts and responsibilities, brought together by the same Spirit to serve the same Lord.

So, Paul has therefore established two important principles: no one is superior because of their gifts, and no one is inferior because of their lack of particular gifts.

But he is not finished. In fact, he is about to show them that even these wonderful gifts that have been given by the Holy Spirit that are so essential to the functioning of the Church are not the most important thing.

Now allow me to paraphrase what I think Paul is trying to say here in verse 31…this is my translation of the Greek: "But while you may earnestly desire the higher gifts, I am showing you a still more excellent way." You see, the Greek verb usually translated "I will show" is actually in the present tense: "I am showing you." So Paul is not simply promising to introduce another subject. He is drawing their attention to something that should already be governing everything they do. In fact, it is the climax of an argument that has been building throughout the letter.

If we were to ask the Corinthians (and perhaps modern-day Christians as well) which spiritual gifts they most admired, we might reasonably expect them to mention speaking in tongues, prophecy, knowledge, extraordinary faith and miraculous works. These were the gifts that seemed (and still seem) to attract attention and confer status. Paul therefore begins by taking their most highly prized gifts and placing them alongside something far more important. Even if someone could speak every human language or possess the ability to communicate in the language of angels, without love that person would amount to little more than a piece of noisy metal.

It is a striking image, particularly in a city accustomed to the noise of pagan worship and the instruments accompanying religious ceremonies. Paul is saying that impressive spiritual speech, however extraordinary, is meaningless when it is disconnected from love.

But then he continues to progressively raise the stakes. Imagine possessing extraordinary prophetic insight, understanding the deepest mysteries of God, having an almost incomprehensible knowledge and exercising a faith capable of moving mountains.

Yet, Paul says, without love, none of that amounts to anything. Indeed, Paul does not merely say that such a person has achieved little. He says that person is nothing.

This is particularly significant when we remember that some of the Corinthians, having acquired spiritual gifts, had begun to regard themselves as important. But Paul is saying that without love, all their newfound status is meaningless.

He then goes further still. Even the most extraordinary acts of generosity and self-sacrifice are of no value if they are not motivated and governed by love. This is an important corrective to the assumption that impressive religious behaviour necessarily demonstrates genuine spirituality.

A person may give everything away and still be selfish. A person may make enormous sacrifices and still be seeking personal recognition. Even the willingness to suffer or die for a cause does not, in itself, establish that the person is acting out of love. Even suffering martyrdom is not something to pursue for personal glory. Christian sacrifice must be governed by rightly ordered love.

Paul's point is unmistakable. Spiritual gifts, knowledge, faith, generosity and even extraordinary sacrifice cannot substitute for love.

But what exactly is love? Paul answers by describing it, not as an emotion or an abstract ideal, but through the actions and attitudes by which it becomes visible.

Now consider how directly this addresses the problems in Corinth. Love is patient. It does not become frustrated with the weaknesses and shortcomings of others. Love is kind. It actively seeks the welfare of others rather than exploiting their vulnerabilities. Love does not envy. It does not resent the gifts, opportunities, or recognition received by someone else. Love does not boast or become arrogant. It does not use its achievements or abilities to elevate itself above others. Love is not rude. It does not behave in ways that humiliate or dishonour another person. Love does not insist on its own way. It is prepared to surrender personal rights for the benefit of others. 

Love is not irritable or resentful. It does not continually revisit past offences or keep a record of wrongs. And finally, love does not rejoice in wrongdoing but rejoices with the truth. 

In other words, the person who is filled with Christian love rejoices in behaviour that reflects the God we serve.

And now Paul concludes with four further expressions. Love bears with the weaknesses and failures of others. It never ceases to trust, even when circumstances are difficult. It never abandons hope that God can bring about transformation, and it perseveres rather than giving up.

This does not mean that love is naïve, ignores wrongdoing, or accepts everything as true. Rather, it means that love remains committed to the welfare of others, always seeking what is good and true…focusing on the positive, rather than on the negative…on what can be, rather than on what is.

But what is particularly important for us to note here is that almost everything Paul says about love is the opposite of what had been happening in Corinth. Indeed, the contrast is devastating. Paul is effectively saying that the Corinthians may possess all the spiritual gifts they desire, but unless their lives demonstrate the love of God, they have fundamentally misunderstood what it means to be spiritual.

The gifts that the Corinthians so highly prize are temporary. Prophecies will pass away. Tongues will cease. Knowledge will be forgotten. All these gifts are necessary for the present, but they belong to an age in which our understanding remains incomplete. "For we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when the perfect comes, the partial will pass away." (13:9–10)

So, Paul is looking towards the completion of God's purposes, when we will no longer need the partial revelation and understanding that characterise our present existence and he illustrates this with the difference between childhood and adulthood.

"When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I gave up childish ways." (13:11) Of course, there is nothing wrong with being a child. Childhood has its own proper place. But we would hardly expect an adult to remain content with the limitations of childhood.

Likewise, our present understanding of God is real, but incomplete and there are limitations of our present knowledge. We see something of God's glory, we understand something of his purposes, and we experience something of his grace, but we do not yet see everything clearly.

However, there is a day coming when that will change. We will see Jesus, face to face. We will know fully, not because we become omniscient, but because the barriers and limitations of our present existence will have been removed. And when that day comes, the spiritual gifts that we now value so highly will have served their purpose.

We will no longer need prophecy to communicate what God has revealed. We will no longer need tongues to overcome the limitations of human communication. We will no longer need partial knowledge because we will see the Lord face to face.

And yet one thing will remain for all eternity. Love will remain. Indeed, love is not simply a gift for the present age. It belongs to the very nature of God and therefore transcends the limitations of this present life.

Faith, hope, and love are the enduring characteristics of Christian existence. Faith looks towards God and trusts him. Hope looks towards the fulfilment of his promises. But love expresses the very character of God. And therefore the greatest of these is love because God himself demonstrated that love, not through the display of extraordinary power, nor through the accumulation of knowledge, nor through the exercise of authority, but through the self-giving sacrifice of his Son.

This is the love we are called to imitate. It is the love that puts others before ourselves…that refuses to exploit or humiliate…that forgives, serves, perseveres, and seeks the good of others.

So, as we draw these two chapters together, I think we need to recognise that Paul has been addressing something far more important than a disagreement about spiritual gifts. He has been challenging the very way we understand what it means to be the Church.

The gifts of the Spirit are given to build up the body, not elevate individuals above it. All our gifts, ministries, knowledge, achievements and sacrifices must be governed by love. Indeed, if we do not love one another, we have missed the very heart of the Gospel.

It is possible to be doctrinally correct but unkind. It is possible to be passionately committed to ministry but insensitive to the needs of others. It is possible to defend the truth while treating those who disagree with us without grace. It is possible to be so concerned with the success of our own ministry that we forget the people we are supposed to be serving.

None of these things are evidence of spiritual maturity. The true measure of our spirituality is whether our lives increasingly reflect the character of Jesus.

And perhaps this is where we need to examine ourselves. Are we patient with one another? Are we kind? Do we rejoice when others are recognised and honoured, or do we quietly resent their success? Do we put the needs of others before our own? Do we bear with one another's weaknesses? Do we persevere in love, even when relationships become difficult? These are not secondary questions. They go to the very heart of what it means to be a Christian community.

The greatest evidence that we truly belong to God is not the gifts we possess, but the love we demonstrate.

So let us earnestly desire the gifts of the Spirit. Let us use whatever God has entrusted to us faithfully and generously. Let us encourage one another, build one another up and recognise the value of every member of Christ's body.

But above all, let us pursue the more excellent way. The Church becomes most spiritually compelling not when it displays how gifted it is, but when it demonstrates how deeply it loves.


Shall we pray?

© Johannes W H van der Bijl 2026

Friday, October 30, 2026

One Bread, One Body: Rediscovering the Lord’s Supper in 1 Corinthians 11:17–34

Psalm 133                           Acts 2:42-47                 1 Corinthians 11:17–34 (ESV)

One Bread, One Body: Rediscovering the Lord’s Supper in 1 Corinthians 11:17–34

There are few passages in the New Testament that have generated as much discussion as Paul’s teaching about the Lord’s Supper in 1 Corinthians 11. Through the centuries, Christians have raised important questions about Christ’s presence in the elements, the nature of the self-examination demanded, as well as the nature of the judgement mentioned. 

But before addressing these questions, we must ask what was happening when the Corinthians gathered. Paul’s assessment in 1 Corinthians 11:17 is devastating: their meetings were doing more harm than good. A meal proclaiming reconciliation had become an occasion for division. The community that confessed that they all belonged to the one body of Jesus were treating each other according to the divisions of their surrounding society. How on earth did this happen? We must assume that a) Paul had taught them the fundamental principles of what it means to be a church and that b) something had radically changed since he had left. 

But to understand Corinth we need to begin with Jerusalem. In Acts 2:42–47, Luke gives us a remarkable portrait of the earliest Christian community following Pentecost. He tells us that the believers devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching, the fellowship, the breaking of bread, and the prayers. These practices express one shared life, shaped by Jesus’ death and resurrection and empowered by the Holy Spirit. Their worship and eating together belonged to the same pattern of Christian fellowship…in other words, their fellowship was not merely a feeling of affection but rather an active participation in a community.

That shared life had material consequences. Believers sold possessions and distributed the proceeds according to need. Acts 4:32–35 develops the picture: their unity meant that the needs of some became the concern of all. Now, it is important to note that this was voluntary, Spirit-generated generosity, not a compulsory surrender of property; Acts 5:4 makes that distinction clear. Nevertheless, their possessions remained resources through which they could serve one another, rather than an abundance to hoard and enjoy without regard for others.

Why am I telling you all this? Well, because I believe Acts 2:42-47 can serve as a paradigm for understanding Paul’s concern in Corinth as it offers a programmatic picture of what the early Christian Community in Jerusalem looked like. Of course, Jerusalem was not flawless. Acts 6 records the neglect of Hellenistic widows. Nevertheless, Luke gives us a pattern against which failures of fellowship can be recognised: teaching, worship, shared meals and generosity all belong together. That pattern helps us see what went wrong in Corinth.

Now, as I’m sure you all know, Early Christians commonly gathered in homes, as numerous verses in the Book of Acts as well as Romans 16:5 and 1 Corinthians 16:19 indicate. Houses and hosts differed in their space and resources, making differences in wealth and status readily visible. In the surrounding society, meals could reinforce those distinctions through the food provided and the treatment of guests. And yet, while Christian fellowship should have challenged that logic, the Corinthian house churches were reproducing it.

In 1 Corinthians 11:18–21, Paul describes divisions within their gathering. Each goes ahead with a personal meal: some remain hungry while others drink to excess. They assemble in one place without acting as one community. Paul’s conclusion is startling: what they are eating cannot truly be called the Lord’s Supper because their conduct contradicts the meaning of the meal.

Verse 22 identifies the offence: they despise God’s church and humiliate those who have nothing. This is more than poor manners or an imperfect ceremony. People lacking basic necessities find their deprivation exposed in the community where they should receive dignity and care. Correct words and familiar ceremonies cannot make worship faithful when participants disregard one another.

Now, to appreciate the possible consequences of this behaviour, we must consider the economic circumstances of Corinth at the time. Archaeological and epigraphic evidence concerning drought, food sources, and economic hardship, including the evidence associated with the grain supplier, Claudius Dinippus, who served several times during the period in which Paul was writing, provides us with a possible historical context for understanding the vulnerability of urban food supplies. 

This background may help explain the seriousness of the hunger of the less fortunate in Corinth. Ancient urban households depended on agricultural supply and trade, and disruptions affected those with few resources most severely. Of course, this context does not prove that a particular shortage lay behind Paul’s rebuke or establish the cause of the illnesses he later mentions, but it does remind us that food insecurity was a real vulnerability, not simply an inconvenience.

For example, consider a day labourer, dependent on finding and maintaining a position to receive wages on a day-to-day basis. If there was a drought, there would be no work. If there was no work, there would be no income. And if there was no income, obtaining food could become impossible. So, while a wealthy household might have reserves, the labourer would have none. 

Translate all this into what was possibly happening in the church, and you are faced with a situation where some members ate abundantly while others remained hungry. As such, the church exposed rather than relieved that vulnerability. In Jerusalem, resources answered need. In Corinth, abundance was enjoyed while need was ignored.

This is why Paul recalls the institution of the Lord’s Supper in verses 23–26. On the night of his betrayal, Jesus gave thanks, broke bread and identified it with his body given for them. The cup signified the new covenant in his blood. Whenever the church shares this bread and cup, it proclaims the Lord’s death until he comes. In other words, the meal receives its meaning from his self-giving.

Now, I do think the language of remembrance also deserves attention. In this sense, remembrance is more than private recollection of a past event. The gathered community remembers the saving act on which its identity rests. As Passover recalled Israel’s deliverance from Egypt, so this meal centres the church on Jesus’ death. Remembering him means recognising both what he has done for us as well as the shared life his sacrifice has created. It gives successive generations a shared identity rooted in God’s saving action through the death of Jesus.

But Jesus’ death means more than the simple termination of his life on the cross. It means that he did not preserve his own privileges at our expense. He gave himself for us…he gave us everything…he withheld nothing. 

The institution narrative therefore grounds Paul’s rebuke. Jesus gave himself for others, yet the Corinthians refused to share their food. They celebrated his immeasurable generosity while practising neglect. But Paul’s point is that those who receive his grace cannot treat fellow recipients as unworthy of dignity. The conduct of the gathered church must be consistent with the self-giving love its meal proclaims.

We now reach the interpretative centre of the passage. In verses 27–29, Paul warns that eating and drinking in an unworthy manner brings guilt concerning the Lord’s body and blood. So, he calls for self-examination and warns against eating without discerning the body. But what does “discerning the body” mean? Our answer must take seriously both the bread and cup, as well as the behaviour Paul has condemned.

Obviously, Christian traditions differ over this warning. Some emphasise recognising Christ’s presence in the bread and wine while others emphasise recognising the church as his body. My own personal reading is that the immediate context strongly supports a communal dimension: the Corinthians must recognise the gathered church as Christ’s body and treat its members accordingly. Paul’s use of “body” elsewhere in this letter supports that interpretation.

For instance, in 1 Corinthians 10:16–17, Paul links participation in Christ’s body and blood with the unity of those sharing the bread in a double metaphor. The many are one body because they partake of one bread, because participation is not an isolated individual experience: belonging to Christ binds the participants to one another. The meaning of the meal and the identity of the community cannot be separated.

The chapter 12:12–27 develops this further. The church is one body with many members, and those who appear weaker are indispensable. Verses 25–26 call for mutual care rather than division: when one member suffers, all suffer together. But in chapter 11, the Corinthians do the exact opposite. They humiliate vulnerable members and ignore their hunger. The shared bread expresses a unity that their conduct denies. They eat the one bread, yet they fail to behave as one body. They proclaim the death of Jesus, yet they disregard the needs of those for whom he died. They receive the signs of fellowship while denying the reality of fellowship.

I therefore understand discerning the body to include recognising the community created through Jesus’ death. The vulnerable believer beside us is not an outsider, a social inferior or an inconvenient reminder of hardship. That person belongs to Christ’s body and deserves dignity and care. The question is not only whether we understand what the bread signifies, but whether we recognise the people with whom we share it. To fail to discern the body as a unity created by every members inclusion through the death of Jesus is to fail to recognise the church for what it is.

This also explains why an offence against fellow believers concerns the Lord’s body and blood. Our relationship with Jesus cannot be detached from our treatment of those who belong to him. Sacramental and communal meanings need not compete: the significance of the bread and the cup makes the participants’ conduct so important. Self-examination must reckon with the division and the neglect Paul actually describes.

But Paul’s warning becomes more serious in verses 30–32. Here he connects their conduct with weakness, illness and deaths among them. Now, one possible historical reconstruction that is consistent with what we know about the situation in Corinth at the time,  is that the poorer members were suffering from inadequate nourishment and the consequences of food insecurity, while those with greater resources enjoyed abundance. In an ancient city, malnutrition, or eating contaminated or rotting food picked up off the streets or from garbage heaps, and preventable illnesses could have devastating consequences, particularly for people without the resources to protect themselves. This reconstruction fits the divisions Paul described. It also helps explain why his instructions focus on sharing the meal and waiting for one another. 

Now there is an illuminating parallel in an early Christian document called the Shepherd of Hermes. In Similitude 3:9 the author warns against enjoying God’s gifts selfishly while others lack what they need. He describes those who overindulge as harming themselves through gluttony, while those with insufficient food waste away from inadequate nourishment. Now, while this doesn’t prove that this is what Paul meant in his letter to the Corinthians, it does demonstrate that early Christian moral reflection could connect the selfish consumption of abundance with bodily harm and neglect of those in need. 

Now, verse 32 adds a crucial distinction: the Lord’s judgement disciplines them so that they will not be condemned with the world. This discipline is corrective, calling the church to repentance rather than leaving it in despair. The community must not dismiss its divisions as trivial and so Paul’s warning leads directly to instructions for changing its shared life.

In verses 33–34, Paul tells them to wait for one another when they gather to eat so that they might learn to eat as a community. Now, the meaning of “eat at home” and the precise arrangements remain disputed. It has often been interpreted as a command for wealthier members to eat their private meals in their private homes before attending the communion meal. But that reading sits uneasily with Paul’s repeated condemnation of the existing divisions and his insistence that the Corinthians should wait for one another.

So, I favour understanding this command in relation to the sharing of meals equally at the house-church gathering, rather than as permission to preserve private, unequal meals. Behind Paul’s instructions to the Corinthians lies the foundational image of the communal spirit of the first church in Jerusalem. Indeed, “…if (Paul) so vehemently objects to the community’s divisive eating habits…and so boldly pronounced judgement upon them…why would he temper his rebuke by sanctioning the church’s wealthier members’ eating (and drinking) at home?” (Henderson, If Anyone Hungers…’: An Integrated Reading of 1 Cor 11:17–34). It doesn’t make sense, does it?

But whatever view we take, disputed details must not obscure Paul’s demand that the church must change how it eats the Lord’s Supper together. There is little point in celebrating a meal that proclaims unity while maintaining practices that destroy unity, so the remedy is the restoration of the integrity of the community. The church must learn to see one another differently and arrange their common life accordingly. 

The contrast with Jerusalem now comes into focus. There, shared worship expressed itself in care for those in need. In Corinth, a meal not shared exposed neglect. The Corinthians had not merely forgotten how to conduct a ceremony; they had forgotten what it meant to belong to one another in Jesus. Social distinctions had displaced the fellowship their Lord’s death had created.

Paul’s words therefore ask us several searching questions. Do we recognise the person beside us as a member of the same body? Do our resources serve those who lack them? Do differences in wealth, education, social influence or background determine how we treat fellow believers? Or do we allow our own personal values to shape our common life as the body of Jesus?

Our participation at the Lord’s table cannot be separated from our answers. We cannot proclaim the self-giving love of Jesus while remaining indifferent to the needs of those for whom he gave himself. We cannot celebrate the one bread while refusing to acknowledge that we are one body. And we certainly cannot claim to discern the body of Christ if we fail to recognise the dignity and needs of its members. 

This does not require everyone to possess the same amount of money or imply that every material difference is inherently unjust, but Paul refuses to let those differences and distinctions excuse humiliation or neglect. The practical test is whether abundance becomes a means of service or a reason to ignore others. We cannot proclaim Jesus’ self-giving love while remaining indifferent to fellow members of his body.

The Lord’s Supper brings us back to the cross: his body given, his blood shed, his death proclaimed until he comes. It also reminds us of all whom he has gathered around his table. We are not unrelated individuals sharing a ceremony, but a people reconciled to God through Jesus and called to live as members of one another.

Let us therefore come with gratitude for his grace, humility about our own needs, and a willingness to recognise and serve one another. Let Jerusalem’s generosity instruct us and Paul’s warning to Corinth search us. May our celebration express, rather than contradict, the love of the Lord who gave himself for us all.

For there is one bread, and we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread.

Shall we pray?

© Johannes W H van der Bijl 2006