Isaiah 53:4-6 Romans 15:1-7 John 19:1-16
Who is in Control?
Last week I mentioned someone some of you had never heard of…a man by the name of Lucius Aelius Sejanus. On October 18, AD 31, this powerful and highly influential man – he was the Prefect of the Praetorian Guard – was arrested and executed, along with many of his followers, for conspiring against Caesar Tiberius. He had been killing supporters of Tiberius (who had retired to Capri) while placing his own supporters in positions of power in an attempt to overthrow Tiberius and make himself Caesar.
Now, the reason I mentioned this man last week and why I am mentioning him now is because Pontius Pilate just happened to be a favoured acquaintance of his and had probably gained the coveted status of “Friend of Caesar” through his influence. You see, it was Sejanus, not Tiberias, who appointed Pilate as proconsul of Judea.
Now, Caiaphas, the High Priest, was far too shrewd a politician not to know what was happening in Rome and he could very well have used the suspicious nature of Tiberius to his advantage. If one sets the date of the trial, sentencing, and execution of Jesus to some time after AD 31, then the fear of following the fate of Sejanus and his supporters must have been uppermost in Pilate’s mind. This would explain his total capitulation after the Jewish leaders played their trump card: “If you release this man,” they shouted, “you are not Caesar’s friend. Everyone who makes himself a king opposes Caesar.”
In the light of this deadly political game of cunning and trickery, the question I would like for us to examine this afternoon is simply this: “Who was in control of the events recorded in our Gospel passage?” Or, to make it a little more practical and applicable: “Who is in control of all things at all times?”
This is not a simple question and should not be answered without much prayer and serious consideration. Of course, it is often easier to answer the question when we look back over time, reevaluating the actions of all parties involved in terms of the eventual consequence, but it is far less easy when we are in the thick of it all, isn’t it?
However, as our Gospel passage draws back the curtain, so to speak, on the most central event of all history, we are given a workable principle – a plumb-line, if you will, against which we may measure all other tragedies, disasters, and wicked plots and deeds. Of course, there are many other passages in Scripture that clearly show how God controls all events, even the decisions of the ungodly to fulfil his higher purpose, but in just about every account, God’s hand appeared to be hidden from those who were involved at the time. However, as Paul reminds us, “whatever was written in former days was written for our instruction, that through endurance and through the encouragement of the Scriptures, we might have hope.” (Romans 15:4)How odd then that we – we who know the Scriptures – we who know the character of our God – we who know his attributes and his promises – how odd then that we often want or even demand an explanation from God concerning the events we face in the present. Surely, what God requires from us, his people, is trust…to trust him despite our uncertainty, our bewilderment, our questions, our ignorance, our suffering, or our discomfort. You see, trust displaces fear (or anxiety) as it boldly states: “I believe what I know to be true, rather than what I am currently experiencing or feeling.”
We begin our Gospel story with another on of Pilate’s strategic moves toward an acquittal. As we saw last week, Pilate knew that Jesus was innocent, yet even so he appeared to be more concerned with his own position as governor than the ethics or morality of the case, and so he stopped short of taking any personal stand. Why he thought that flogging Jesus would change the Jewish leader’s position is anyone’s guess as they had already clearly stated that they wanted him dead…but as he did not seem to have the courage to defend what he knew to be right, they played with him as a cat plays with its prey until he was forced to make a decision contrary to what he knew to be true.
Now, the flogging procedure involved stripping the victim and binding them to a post or a pillar. They were then beaten by several torturers, one following another, until the victim’s flesh hung in bloody shreds. In the provinces, soldiers usually carried out this task.
Three types of implements were commonly used. Rods, sticks, and scourges or whips. These scourges or whips were made of leather thongs fitted with spikes or pieces of bone or metal and it was more than likely this implement that was used on Jesus. This method of punishment was brutal. It was reported that victims often collapsed or died during the ordeal even though it was never intended to be used as a means of execution. First century historian, Flavius Josephus wrote about having his own opponents flogged until their entrails were exposed.
This is probably the reason why Jesus was unable to carry his cross all the way to the place of crucifixion. But I’ve described this awful procedure because I simply cannot understand why Pilate prescribed such a vicious beating for a man he believed was innocent. True, he was often described by his contemporaries as exceptionally hard and cruel and, according to Josephus, he was was later removed from office because he violently and savagely suppressed a Samaritan uprising at Mount Gerizim, but this still does not explain his actions here.
There are only three possible reasons, I think, why Pilate chose to have Jesus flogged. The first is that perhaps he hoped that the horrific result of the flogging would engender sympathy from Jesus’ accusers and gain support for his plan to acquit Jesus. The second possible reason is that he might have thought that the vision of a bloodied pulp of a man would prove to everyone that Jesus was no threat to Rome. The final possible reason is that if the flogging had had a fatal result, the accusers would have been satisfied while he would be free from moral guilt of having ordered the execution of a man, he believed to be innocent.
Whatever the reason, imagine Pilate’s total exasperation when this did not have any impact on the leaders of the Jews! His response to their insistence that he crucify Jesus shows disgust and anger. And yet we know that a higher hand was moving them to do his bidding as Isaiah tells us that it was “the will of the Lord to crush him.” Even so, although both Pilate and the Sanhedrin were repeatedly confronted with the truth, they remained completely blind to it.
Now, the Sanhedrin’s appeal to the Jewish law against blasphemy in verse 7 did not negate the political charge but rather added a religious one. They caftilly blended together Jewish and Roman law to a) force Pilate’s hand and to b) exonerate or absolve themselves in the eyes of the crowds.
But this new accusation seemed to fill Pilate with fear and awe. You must remember, both Greek and Roman mythology tell stories of the gods taking on human form and punishing the mortals who mistreated them.
So, in this fit of pure pagan panic, Pilate questioned Jesus again. But note that this time he asked him where he was from, probably expecting him to say Mount Olympus. But when Jesus refused to stoop to the level of pagan mythology, Pilate’s frustration boiled over into a threat. “You will not speak to me?” he probably shouted. “Do you not know that I have authority to release you and authority to crucify you?”
Now, the absurdity of this statement is almost laughable. Pilate may have been Caesar’s representative in Judea…he may have wielded great authority…but he was standing before one whom he feared might be one of the gods, but who was, in reality, the one and only true God.
But it is at this point that Jesus revealed to Pilate the true source of all authority, a reply that was at once both a rebuke and a comfort. All are subject and answerable to God. And yet, while Pilate was by no means excused, his sin was less than those who had initiated this trial because they should have known better…they were the custodians of God’s Law. As James later wrote in his Epistle: “Not many of you should become teachers, my brothers, for you know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness.” (James 3:1)
But what Pilate needed to learn, and perhaps what we need to learn, is that all human authority is derived authority, and his power was measured by the One who is, at all times, in perfect and absolute control of all events…even those done by the ungodly and the wicked. The only reason Pilate had the power to crucify Jesus was because it was divinely ordained. Even the schemes of the wicked are tools in the hands of God.
This statement of Jesus made Pilate even more determined to have him released, but it is at this point that the Jewish leaders played their trump card. The phrase “friend of Caesar” was a technical term which meant that such a one was loyal to the emperor. To lose the status would most certainly mean political doom for Pilate. But their use of a term more than likely gained by his friendship with Sejanus would have set all alarm bells ringing and so Pilate conceded defeat, but not without one last ditch effort.
Pilate’s statement, “Behold your King” may have been an attempt to excuse himself of blame if Jesus really was a god, or perhaps, a son of the Jewish God. Remember, he believed in a pantheon/plurality/superfluity of gods, so he may have been accusing them of mistreating their God.
The response of the Jewish leaders – “We have no king but Caesar!” – is surprising to say the least. God alone was the King of Israel. And yet with this blasphemy on their lips, they embraced the sovereignty of a pagan man who claimed divinity while rejecting Jesus who was divine! The irony of it all! And then, after having rejected their God and deliverer, they celebrated the Passover!
But if you have read through the Old Testament this rejection of God as their God or as their King had happened many times in the course of their history. It is equally interesting to note that Pilate’s sentencing of Jesus is not exactly recorded in the Gospels…as John said here, “He delivered him over to them to be crucified.” This may explain why Jesus said to his Jewish accusers in John 8:28, “When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you will know that I am he…” In this action, or perhaps in this inaction, Pilate may have inadvertently fulfilled Jesus’ prophetic statement, again a reminder of who was really in control.
So, who was to blame for the crucifixion of Jesus? Judas? Caiaphas? The Sanhedrin? The cowardly secret believers who should have intervened? Pilate? Humanity in general? Yes, they were all responsible and all wil be held accountable, but although it was the evil deeds of evil people that made this awful crime possible, who was in control of all events? The Scriptures make it clear that behind the scenes of human injustice the hand of God works to do whatever he has determined beforehand to do. (Acts 4:27-28)
Are you struggling with a sense of injustice or unfairness? Perhaps you are a product of a broken or an abusive home or you were bullied at school and have often wondered where God was during your childhood. Or perhaps you are presently dealing with some painful situation and your trust in God is being severely tested. While there may be no easy answers to our various questions, this passage, as well as many others in Scripture, directs our searching hearts up to the throne of the one who has promised to work all things…all things…good and bad things…he has promised to work all things together for the good of those who love him. (Romans 8:28)
It is as we rest and trust on the will and purpose of a God whose thoughts toward us are for good only and whose plans for us are to prosper us…it is only then that we begin to come to terms with the seemingly unnecessary evil things in life. Remember, it was because of the joy that was set before him that Jesus was able to endure the cross. (Hebrews 12:2) True, we may never fully comprehend his reasoning, but if we believe that he directs our lives as he directed the life of Jesus, then we can be assured that our various paths – smooth, rocky, or steep – will lead to life.
Shall we pray?
© Johannes W H van der Bijl 2025