Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Tongues, Prophecy, and Worship

Psalm 117                             Isaiah 28:9-13                        1 Corinthians 14       
(and 1 Peter 1:18–19 to be read during the sermon by me)
Tongues, Prophecy, and Worship

Think of a physical gift that you would consider priceless…something essential to your happiness and wellbeing as a believer. I know you’re thinking of Jesus and salvation, but for now, think of a physical gift other than Jesus.
Thought of that gift? Do you have it in mind? Good.
Now I want you to read the following two verses with me.
"For you know that it was not with perishable things such as silver or gold that you were redeemed from the empty way of life handed down to you from your ancestors, but with the precious blood of Christ, a lamb without blemish or spot." (1 Peter 1:18–19)
Let’s read that again, shall we? Did you see that?
That priceless gift is…your fellow believer. Each of us has been redeemed with the precious and priceless blood of Jesus, so you cannot put a price on your life or mine. And here comes the best part: God has gifted us to each other. You are God’s priceless gift to me, and I am God’s priceless gift to you. 
So, now I’m going to do something totally not me and ask you to stand up, and to turn to the people around you, and to look them in the eye and say, “You are God’s gift to me”. 
Just as the eye is a gift to the foot and the hand is a gift to the ear, so we are God’s gifts to each other to make us function together as his Body…his hands and his feet here on earth.

Now, let’s turn to 1 Corinthians 14. Tongues, prophecy, other supernatural gifts, and the puzzling command for women to be silent can so capture our attention that we miss Paul’s point which is the purpose of the Church. And Paul has already told us what that purpose is.
At the end of chapter 12, he says, “…I am showing you the most excellent way.” And then, in Chapter 13, he spells out biblical love. Now, in chapter 14, he goes on to show how the gifts that have divided them can instead unify and edify the whole body.
In Paul’s mind, the question has never been, “Which gift do I have?” It is not even, “Which gift is the most impressive?” The question is and always will be: “How do I use what God has given me to exhibit biblical love to the priceless gifts God has given to me?” That is the governing principle of this entire chapter.
Paul begins: “(So,) pursue love and (or you could say, but also) eagerly desire gifts of the Spirit, especially prophecy.”
I want you to notice the balance here: pursue love AND desire spiritual gifts. Paul will not let us choose one instead of the other. The gifts of the Spirit are instruments through which God’s love is expressed within the body of Christ.
Now, of course, as we’ve said before, the gifts are not the goal. Love is the goal because of all the gifts love alone is eternal. Nevertheless, in the present, the gifts are the means by which the Spirit enables us to love and serve one another. And this brings us back to something we have already spoken about before.
God is love. So, if we belong to him, his character ought to be visible in our words, our actions, and the way we use our gifts.
But love does not simply happen to us. We must practise it and grow in it. That is why Paul says, “Pursue love.” 
But as we’ve already seen, he also says, “eagerly desire spiritual gifts.”
So the question we should be asking as believers is: “How can I express biblical love by using the gifts God has given me?”
That is what Paul means by spiritual maturity. Gifts must build the body.
In this chapter, Paul begins by comparing tongues with prophecy. He says that the person speaking in a tongue speaks to God, because nobody understands what is being said. In other words, whatever these “tongues” are, they are not intelligible languages, but spiritual languages. But on the other hand, the person who prophesies speaks to people “for their strengthening, encouraging and comfort.”
Now, perhaps we need to more closely define what is meant by the word “prophecy”. Prophecy can involve foretelling…predicting the future. But in Scripture it is more frequently forthtelling: proclaiming God’s truth into a particular situation.
The Old Testament prophets chiefly applied God’s truth, revealed primarily in the Torah, to his people. They challenged, encouraged, warned, convicted, and called them back to faithfulness. 
And this is what I think Paul has in mind here.
In the gathered church, prophecy is the Spirit-enabled proclamation and application of God's truth so that God's people are strengthened, encouraged and comforted. However, because it is being spoken publicly, it is also subject to evaluation.
And that is important. Nobody in the Church ever gets to say, “God told me this, therefore you must accept it.” No, Paul later says that the other church members must carefully evaluate what was said. In other words, all prophetic speech, including my sermons, is subject to, and accountable to, biblical truth. 
That should make us humble whenever we stand up to teach or speak. The words of anyone claiming to speak for God must always be tested against Scripture.
However, Paul goes on to say that “The one who prophesies is greater than the one who speaks in tongues, unless that person interprets, so that the church may be edified.”
And the key word here is the last word: edified. The way we know whether or not the use of a spiritual gift is loving is simply whether it builds up the body or breaks down the body.
In this light, let’s quickly look at the difficult subject of tongues. I think Paul is remarkably clear about something that we sometimes miss. He does not deny that the gift of tongues is genuine. In fact, he says explicitly: “I thank God that I speak in tongues more than all of you.”
So Paul is not attacking the gift. As always, his concern is how the gift is used when the church gathers.
So, I think it would be good for us to figure out what this gift of tongues is because the same word seems to be used in Scripture to refer to known languages as well as unknown (or unintelligible) languages. 
And I think a good place for us to start is Acts 2. At Pentecost, people gathered in Jerusalem from many nations heard the disciples declaring God’s mighty works in their own languages. So, the miracle was understandable (or known) speech. And the same pattern seems to appear when the Spirit comes upon new groups of believers elsewhere in Acts, such as in Acts 10 and Acts 19. 
“Although scholars debate whether the ‘tongues’ in Acts (19:6) were ecstatic speech or recognizable languages, the safest narrative reading within Luke’s literary framework is to understand them as known human languages in continuity with Acts 2. Luke consistently presents tongues as public, verifiable signs accompanying key redemptive-historical expansions of the church (Acts 2; 10; 19), and he gives no indication that the phenomenon in (Caesarea and in) Ephesus differs in kind from Pentecost.” 
However, Corinth appears different in one crucial respect: those present could not understand the languages being spoken. So, Paul’s practical question is: What good does that do the church?
Imagine me speaking for ten minutes (you wish) in a language none of you understands. However genuine and spiritually inspired I may be, what have I given you? Nothing you can understand or respond to.
And that is precisely Paul's point. Paul is not asking whether the gift is authentic. He is asking whether its public use is loving. You see, something can be genuinely spiritual and still be used unlovingly. That was Paul’s concern in Corinth: real gifts were being used for self-elevation rather than service.
Their desire for attention, status, and spiritual prestige contradicted chapter 13. And that is why Paul says he would rather speak five intelligible words to instruct others than ten thousand words in a tongue.
As Douglas Moo puts it, Paul does not disparage the gift of tongues; rather, he is saying that “using intelligible words to instruct others” is the much better option. 
You see, the gift is not the problem. It is the self-centred use of the gift that is the problem.
At this point, Paul gives us several illustrations of instruments that must make distinguishable sounds…a flute, a harp, and a trumpet that must give a clear call. Imagine being on a battlefield and hearing a trumpet. But you can’t tell whether the call means “advance,” “retreat,” “assemble,” or “attack.”
The sound may be beautiful, but if nobody understands it, it has failed in its purpose. And Paul says: “So it is with you.” The church must speak in a way that people can understand. Why? Because intelligibility is an act of love.
If I communicate helpful truth in language you cannot understand, I have not served you. Complicated teaching that leaves you knowing less, or theological language used to display my knowledge, spirituality, or education, misses the point entirely.
Love compels me to ask: Can the other person understand me? And that is why Paul says: “Since you are eager for the gifts of the Spirit, try to excel in those that build up the church.” That is Christian maturity.
So, Paul encourages those speaking in unintelligible tongues to pray for the gift of interpretation. Now, if I understand verse 13 correctly, the speaker should pray for that gift for themselves, rather than necessarily relying on a second person to interpret. Either way, Paul’s concern is not to prohibit the gift, but to ensure that its public use is understood by all.
Paul then says something particularly interesting in verse 14: “I will pray with my spirit, but I will also pray with my understanding; I will sing with my spirit, but I will also sing with my understanding.”
For Paul, the spiritual and the intellectual belong together. Christian worship engages the whole person: we love God with our heart and our mind.
This, of course, raises the question of how can the person beside us say “Amen” if they do not understand? You see, worship is not just about me and God; it is about us collectively and God. We gather as the body and therefore, what I do affects you, and what you do affects me.
So private and public use of gifts must be distinguished. Paul says he speaks in tongues himself, but among believers he prefers five understandable words to ten thousand that nobody can comprehend.
Please note that he is not denying the private use of the gift. Rather, he is insisting that public worship must be ordered around the edification of the whole body.
And this is where Paul's quotation from Isaiah becomes so powerful. He quotes Isaiah 28: “With other tongues and through the lips of foreigners I will speak to this people, but even then, they will not listen to me.” The background to this quotation is illuminating because Isaiah was speaking to people who had already rejected God's clear and understandable word.
God had spoken plainly to them, but they refused to listen and so eventually God's judgment came through the lips of foreign conquerors. They heard languages they could not understand and that was the judgement.
So Paul applies that warning to Corinth with devastating irony: speech they treated as proof of spiritual superiority could instead signal spiritual alienation, making people who belong feel like outsiders. That is the opposite of what the church should be.
The church should welcome outsiders into God’s presence. Consequently, if an unbeliever hears only unintelligible spiritual language, they may conclude, “These people are out of their minds.” But clearly proclaimed truth, on the other hand, may expose the secrets of their heart, convict them of their meaningless ways, and lead them to recognise that God is really among us.
So, Paul’s emphasis is on our encounter with the living God, not an impressive spiritual performance. The church is not a spiritual theatre; we are here to help one another encounter God and so, everything we do must be done in love.
And now Paul brings the whole discussion together.
He says: “When you come together, each of you has a hymn, or a word of instruction, a revelation, a tongue or an interpretation. (But) everything must be done so that the church may be built up.”
Notice that Paul does not picture a congregation where only one person contributes. These church services were obviously very different in form to ours…and, dare I say, much, much longer. 
Be that as it may, Paul says that the Spirit has distributed these gifts throughout the body, not merely to a select few. But Paul also does not imagine everybody exercising those gifts simultaneously, because love requires restraint. Perhaps this is one of the most important lessons in this chapter. While everyone is encouraged to use their gifts for the benefit of everyone else, each one of us is being checked in some way.
The tongue-speaker, the prophet, the person wishing to speak or evaluate…all are checked. So too, in the difficult final section, are those interrupting or publicly challenging or evaluating others.
Not because sharing the gifts is bad, but because the body matters more than the individual expression of the gift.
So, Paul tells us that only two or three may speak in tongues…and only one at a time…and only if there is an interpretation. If there is no interpretation, the person should remain silent in the assembly.
Two or three prophets may speak. The others should evaluate. And if another revelation comes to someone sitting down, the first speaker should give them a chance to speak as well.
As Paul says: “For you can all prophesy in turn so that everyone may be instructed and encouraged.” “In turn” means that no gift entitles anyone to dominate. His point is that in the use of the gifts, the Holy Spirit does not remove self-control: having something to say does not compel us to say it immediately. We can wait and listen. Sometimes the most spiritual thing we can do is remain silent.
And speaking about being silent, we now come to the passage that has caused enormous difficulty in the church: “Women should remain silent in the churches.”
Now, we must read this statement carefully alongside chapter 11, where Paul already describes women praying and prophesying in the gathered church. So, whatever he means here, it cannot be an absolute prohibition on speaking in the assembly without contradicting what he has already written.
It is important to note that the immediate context in which this statement is found, concerns evaluating prophecy. So, it is possible that some women were publicly questioning their husbands (or worse, other women’s husbands) during the assembly. In a Roman colony such as Corinth, this could be perceived as a serious breach of social and marital propriety, especially when one married woman questioned another woman’s husband.
There is an illuminating speech of Cato the Elder recorded in the Roman historian Livy’s “History of Rome”. In the speech Cato rebukes Roman women who were publicly approaching magistrates and other men. He says, “For my part, I blushed when, a short while ago, I walked through the midst of a band of women. Had I not been restrained by modesty and respect for the dignity of some of them rather than by fear, lest I should be mobbed by them, I should have said: ‘What sort of practice is this, running out into the streets and blocking the roads and (here comes the important bit) speaking to other women’s husbands? Could you not have asked your own husbands the same thing at home?’”  
So Paul’s concern appears to be public interrogation of male prophets by women in a cultural setting where that could be considered socially improper. In other words, this is not a total ban on women speaking in the church service as that would contradict 1 Corinthians 11:5. In this case, as with all the others, the principle remains the same: love restrains itself for the sake of the body.
So, what Paul is saying here is that there are circumstances in which even a legitimate question must wait. Sometimes the question can be asked later. Sometimes it can be discussed at home. Sometimes we must simply listen. And again, the principle is not “Who has the right to speak?” The principle is: What will build up the body? That is Paul's concern from beginning to end. Order is not the enemy of the Spirit.
Consequently, Paul says: “For God is not a God of disorder but of peace.” That does not mean that a Spirit-filled church is lifeless or that worship must be cold and mechanical or that spontaneity is wrong. It means that the freedom of the Spirit is never freedom from love and love exercises restraint when restraint is the loving thing to do.
And so Paul finishes: “Therefore, my brothers and sisters, be eager to prophesy, and do not forbid speaking in tongues. But everything should be done in a fitting and orderly way.”
Notice how balanced Paul is. He does not forbid the use of spiritual gifts. He just tells us to use them properly to build up or edify the whole body.
And that brings us back to where we began. “Pursue love.”
Of course, the gifts matter. Prophecy matters. Teaching matters. Encouragement, prayer, and singing all matter. Every gift that God gives matters.
But none of these gifts are given so that we can draw attention to ourselves. They are given so that Christ may be seen in all of us as we are God’s most precious gifts to each other and to the world.
Perhaps the simplest way to summarise 1 Corinthians 14 is this: The God of love gives us gifts, and the God of love teaches us how to use them. And when the church exercises restraint and does all things in an orderly fashion for the sake of the edification of all, Paul says something extraordinary can happen.
The outsider can experience the divine when they walk through our doors. The broken can find healing. The confused can find truth. The unbeliever can encounter God.
And that is exactly what we want. Not that people should see how gifted we are, but that, through the way we love one another, they should see Jesus.

Shall we pray?
© Johannes W H van der Bijl 2026

van der Bijl, Johannes W H, 1 Corinthians: A Life in Letters. Carlisle: Langham Publishing, 2026, 277.
Moo, Douglas, A Theology of Paul. Biblical Theology of the New Testament. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2021, 150.
See van der Bijl, 279.

No comments:

Post a Comment